User Name
Password
AppleNova Forums » Apple Products »

Airport Express Base Station-How reliable as server hard drive? Which Hard Drive?


Register Members List Calendar Search FAQ Posting Guidelines
Airport Express Base Station-How reliable as server hard drive? Which Hard Drive?
Thread Tools
markw10
Awaiting Email Confirmation
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
 
2007-01-16, 01:47

I made the choice to get a Airport Express Base Station and actually ordered one today and can't wait to get it. I have a network set up where I have a MacBook Pro and soon my fiancee will be getting a MacBook Pro as well. My main server computer is currently a Windows XP based machine but my original plan was to replace this with a Mac Pro this summer.

We both have our own home based businesses which are as well internet based businesses so a reliable computer network and internet is important. Currently our Windows XP server is not that reliable but most of our data (Office files, inDesign files, PDF's, Photoshop files, as well as Dreamweaver and other web page development files) is actually stored on our laptops themselves. Also, even many of our media files (mp3's, some videos, and especially photos is stored on our laptops. Larger files such as final cut pro projects we are working on as well as other media files we don't store on our laptops and files that we share in our businesses or rarely used files are stored on this server hard drive but most often this server acts as a 'backup hard drive' for our laptops in case we were to lose one or have a hard drive crash and it acts vice versa of course also. It also works as a printer server for a usb all in one fax/copier/printer.

The more I looked at the airport base station I realized this could act as my server. Obviously the usb printer could be hooked in to it to act as a network printer but now that it can accept one or more hard drives it looks even more likely. I can see myself purchasing a 250-500 gig usb external hard drive and simply plugging it in to make a 'network' drive which my server currently has.

1. Reliabilty: My main concern is reliability. When I first switch to Mac a couple months ago I was warned that when it comes to external drives use firewire, not USB, since USB is not as reliable. Maybe someday airport base stations will offer firewire but how reliable are these usb hard drives?

2. Speed: I know USB 2.0 offers 480Mbps which seems like more than enough speed but does that offer enough speed compared to if I had a hard drive directly in the computer? For example if I'm using Final Cut Pro working on a video file will it work okay working across the network at 'n' networking speeds or will it want me to be doing it on a computer with the hard drive actually inside that specific computer?

3. Which hard drive: For internal drives I've always preferred Maxtor but now that it's coming to External drives is there any specific type, brand, etc? that I should look for? I have seen some very nice, under $200, 500GB drives. As well, I like the western digital portable hard drives and have seen a 120GB model for around $100 which would be great to use as a backup drive (which can then later be stored in a safe) or even on the go in a laptop bag.

4. Backup Type: In addition to the main hard drive and printer I want to use a hard drive at times for backup. Is there any specific Mac sofware that is great to do either a file by file backup or one large file (compressed file) backup to a network hard drive?

5. Hubs: Obviously with these multiple devices I need a good USB 2.0 hub but beyond that do I need any specific hub?

I know this won't totally satisfy my desire for a desktop Mac. I'm sure I'll get one with time but at least I can put off my purchase longer having a reliable network drive/printer and also when I purchase a desktop Mac I can likely get a less costly setup.
I know this is a lot of questions but thanks in advance for any help.
  quote
danielsza
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Hamilton, On
Send a message via AIM to danielsza Send a message via MSN to danielsza  
2007-01-16, 02:15

Quote:
Originally Posted by markw10 View Post

1. Reliabilty: My main concern is reliability. When I first switch to Mac a couple months ago I was warned that when it comes to external drives use firewire, not USB, since USB is not as reliable. Maybe someday airport base stations will offer firewire but how reliable are these usb hard drives?

2. Speed: I know USB 2.0 offers 480Mbps which seems like more than enough speed but does that offer enough speed compared to if I had a hard drive directly in the computer? For example if I'm using Final Cut Pro working on a video file will it work okay working across the network at 'n' networking speeds or will it want me to be doing it on a computer with the hard drive actually inside that specific computer?

3. Which hard drive: For internal drives I've always preferred Maxtor but now that it's coming to External drives is there any specific type, brand, etc? that I should look for? I have seen some very nice, under $200, 500GB drives. As well, I like the western digital portable hard drives and have seen a 120GB model for around $100 which would be great to use as a backup drive (which can then later be stored in a safe) or even on the go in a laptop bag.

4. Backup Type: In addition to the main hard drive and printer I want to use a hard drive at times for backup. Is there any specific Mac sofware that is great to do either a file by file backup or one large file (compressed file) backup to a network hard drive?

5. Hubs: Obviously with these multiple devices I need a good USB 2.0 hub but beyond that do I need any specific hub?

I know this won't totally satisfy my desire for a desktop Mac. I'm sure I'll get one with time but at least I can put off my purchase longer having a reliable network drive/printer and also when I purchase a desktop Mac I can likely get a less costly setup.
I know this is a lot of questions but thanks in advance for any help.
1) USB drives work okay and they should be fine being used with the Airport. As for firewire there are a few reasons why it's better. But since apple wants to get more users (switchers) and most likely they will only have USB drives, kinda like the iPod.

2) No the transfer will be too slow even at 'N', for FCP. For FCP you should use a firewire drive ((or firewire 800) or eSATA (if you get a eSATA card)) that is a local drive. The most you would want to keep on a NAS device would be still pictures to be used for FCP.

3) Any brand should be fine. I would buy the enclosure by it's self, and then get any hard drive you like. I like segate because of the 5 year warranty they have. But if you buy an external drive from them, then it's only a 1 year warranty

4) Leopard will have time machine. But there are a few apps that you could use... or you create a shell script or an apple script to take care of backing up files for you.

5) Any USB 2.0 hub should work fine.
  quote
markw10
Awaiting Email Confirmation
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
 
2007-01-16, 02:31

I have heard of Super Duper but haven't tried it but am going to read up on Time Machine. Sounds like my best buy is to buy an external USB drive specifically for my laptop for using FCP
  quote
danielsza
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Hamilton, On
Send a message via AIM to danielsza Send a message via MSN to danielsza  
2007-01-16, 02:41

I believe that Super Duper makes a copy of the entire drive. I'm not sure if that's what your looking for. And it would be best to buy a external hard drive to use with FCP, but I would go with Firewire or firewire 800 (if it has a firewire 800 port)
  quote
tobes
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
 
2007-01-16, 06:47

Super Duper is fantastic - creates a bootable image of your HDD, so if the system goes down you have the option of booting from the external drive, or reformat your disk and copy the external over (I've no connection with it, just a happy user).

Toby
  quote
beardedmacuser
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: eastmidlandshire
 
2007-01-16, 06:58

Quote:
Originally Posted by tobes View Post
Super Duper is fantastic - creates a bootable image of your HDD, so if the system goes down you have the option of booting from the external drive, or reformat your disk and copy the external over (I've no connection with it, just a happy user).
If all you're wanting to do is create an image of your OS X boot volume, then Apple's Disc Utility will do that just fine too (running from a healthy OS X install or from the OS X install CD if your Mac won't boot from the hard drive).
  quote
malcolm
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Canada
 
2007-01-16, 10:33

My advice re external fw drives is just this: get one (or put one) in a fw enclosure that has a fan, not just a heat-sink. I think it's more dependable.
mhchc
  quote
Posting Rules Navigation
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Post Reply

Forum Jump
Thread Tools
Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Can I use both Wi-Fi (Airport Express Base Station) and Ethernet Lan on Mac Pro? markw10 Genius Bar 5 2007-01-15 19:28
"update" process & hard drive ticking -- Calling *nix gurus! Brad Genius Bar 77 2006-05-19 19:50
External Hard Drive. Is Spin-down possible? Ichiban_jay Genius Bar 5 2005-09-21 19:32
can't find hard drive to install osx! Veej007 Genius Bar 23 2005-05-23 15:17
Which hard drive should I buy? bholtzman Purchasing Advice 24 2005-04-25 20:59


« Previous Thread | Next Thread »

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:21.


Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2024, AppleNova