User Name
Password
AppleNova Forums » Purchasing Advice »

Buy New 15" PowerBook or wait for Intel ???


Register Members List Calendar Search FAQ Posting Guidelines
Buy New 15" PowerBook or wait for Intel ???
Page 1 of 2 [1] 2  Next Thread Tools
MacMan05
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
 
2005-10-21, 18:12

Hi,

Should I buy the newly updated PowerBooks or wait for the Intel change?

If I were to wait for the change, what kind of benefit would there be besides specs wise? Would one be able to run both Win/Mac software on the same machine?

Any advice or input would be greatly appreciated...

Last edited by MacMan05 : 2005-10-21 at 18:26.
  quote
Koodari
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
 
2005-10-21, 20:01

Quote:
Originally Posted by MacMan05
Hi,

Should I buy the newly updated PowerBooks or wait for the Intel change?

If I were to wait for the change, what kind of benefit would there be besides specs wise? Would one be able to run both Win/Mac software on the same machine?

Any advice or input would be greatly appreciated...
The 15":s are damn good right now. Update is probably half a year away.
Expect a small bump in graphics (but the current 9700 chip is pretty good), and a processor that is quite a bit faster mainly due to faster bus.
No one knows if the machines can dualboot to Windows. It is more unlikely than on desktops, anyway, due to everything being more integrated.
  quote
RC23
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
 
2005-10-21, 20:10

it really depends...
buying a G4 chip right now is like buying a 1970 Ford Truck.
  quote
Lee_Roy
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
 
2005-10-21, 20:14

I say save your money and buy an iBook and max the ram out. Then buy a Mac desktop with intel inside next year. That is my plan. Got me a 12" iBook and in a year or year and a half I'll get an Intel inside mac. Basically if you are gonna use the laptop for mostly surfing the web/music/email then get the iBook. If you want power too may get an iBook and a 17" iMac.
  quote
Ryan
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Promise Land of Trustafarians
 
2005-10-21, 20:36

This goes by the age-old rule, if you need it now, buy it. If you can wait, wait.

BTW, this should be in Purchasing Advice.
  quote
MacMan05
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
 
2005-10-21, 20:57

The only thing that bugs me about the iBooks is their slow 4200 rpm hdd, 32MB DDR video memory and display resolution of 1024x768.

I guess I could ebay it for a small loss and buy the Intel PB's when they finally hit store shelves...
  quote
MacMan05
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
 
2005-10-21, 20:58

Guess I can wait....
  quote
MCQ
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: NY
Send a message via MSN to MCQ  
2005-10-21, 21:21

What are you using it for?
  quote
MacMan05
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
 
2005-10-21, 21:53

I just visited macmall.com and they are offering a free memory upgrade of 1GB from Lifetime Memory. It's $218 initially, with a mail-in rebate of $179. Ofcourse there is an installation fee of $39.99. I assume they'll give me the 512MB that's already inside.

Have you ever heard of this brand memory? This a good deal?
  quote
MacMan05
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
 
2005-10-21, 21:57

I have lot's of digital pics and home movies i'd like to edit. Also for general use.

Eventually I hope to get into the heavy graphics stuff, but thats later down the road.
  quote
badtzmaru
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
 
2005-10-24, 16:39

I was also struggling with whether to buy a new 15" PowerBook (my current PowerBook is an 18-month old 1.25Ghz model, my first Apple and what I use exclusively) or wait for Intel, so I thought I'd share what I've been contemplating and considering...

1) I've invested quite a bit of money into PowerPC-OSX software including Final Cut, Peak 4 Pro, Adobe Creative Suite, MS Office w' Virtual PC, and Toast 7; probably over $2000 in software. When the Intel-PowerBook becomes available, and if I want true application performance to make having an Intel-PowerBook worthwhile, I'm going to want to also update my software to Intel-OSX versions. Depending on the software, the company, and my current software version, there might be upgrade pricing available or one might have to pay full price for a new Intel-OSX version of software; who knows? So in my case a move to an Intel PowerBook could potentially cost around $4500 to $5000 to me, give or take, which is the best I'm going by in the absence of clear info.

2) Will the first Intel-PowerBook on the streets be the one to get? Is it wise to chance buying into the first generation of Intel Macs, which is a major hardware revision? If the new Intel-PowerBook's CPU is based on Yonah, maybe its better to wait until a Merom-based Intel PowerBook is available, expected to be a better CPU power and performance-wise. That could be 2007 at the earliest.

3) I'd like a better Mac since I'm getting impatient with my 1.25Ghz PowerBook. I want a bigger on-board hard drive and a faster CPU for video work and rendering.

So I decided that I'm going to buy a new 20" iMac G5 for home use, and have my current PowerBook for mobile use and side-tasks at home (like DV video rips that I can walk away from). This gives me better performance at home and an opportunity to maximize my software investment. As time progresses and the parts get cheaper, I may upgrade my PowerBook's hard drive to 7200rpm (like >120GB) and the DVD to a 8x-DL model. I'd probably also upgrade the iMac's hard drive and memory as the prices drop over time.

I figure that in this way: I can maximize my use of the software I currently have that's more than adequate for my needs; add a G5 with a 20" display for home use (which I can't imagine would have lower performance that the first Intel-PowerBooks that are released); and buy myself at least couple years until the Intel transition shakes out.
  quote
Luca
ಠ_ರೃ
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Minnesota
 
2005-10-24, 17:01

I'd say that anyone who already owns an aluminum PowerBook should NOT buy a new one. There's no reason to. Apple hasn't really improved the PowerBooks since they unified the lineup in late 2003. They haven't added any important new features, only gimmicks. The increase in clock speed is both disappointingly small and almost entirely insignificant. The biggest changes, I'd say, would be:

- Better battery life
- Superdrive as standard equipment
- Hard drive speeds increased to 5400/7200 RPM from 4200 RPM

All three of these can be applied to any aluminum PowerBook G4. If your battery is failing, you can buy a new one. If you need a DVD burner or a faster hard drive, those can be added as well (though it'll void your warranty if you install them yourself). If necessary you can add them via external cases. My point is that there aren't any significant changes to the PowerBook line, so there's no reason to buy a new one when you can get an old one for cheaper.
  quote
chucker
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: near Bremen, Germany
Send a message via ICQ to chucker Send a message via AIM to chucker Send a message via MSN to chucker Send a message via Yahoo to chucker Send a message via Skype™ to chucker 
2005-10-24, 17:17

Quote:
Originally Posted by Luca
They haven't added any important new features, only gimmicks.
I'm not sure I can agree with this.

Consider:
  1. (2) The sudden motion sensor: lifesaver for me (I've had three hard drive deaths with this iBook in the past 18 months, with two different models, from two different manufacturers, so i can't blame it on anything in particular)
  2. (2) The scrolling trackpad (gimmicky for some, maybe, but considered convenient by many)
  3. (1*) Safe Sleep
  4. (1*) The far higher resolution
  5. (1*) The improved battery, (1*) screen brightness and (2*) keyboard illumination brightness

(1) Current revision
(2) Previous revision

I think that's a lot of additional features. All minor on their own, but, in total, rather major. Of course, here goes the 12-inch argument again, since all changes marked * don't even apply to it. But this thread is about the 15-inch model. Altogether, I would definitely say that these changes make it a lot more valuable.
  quote
Luca
ಠ_ರೃ
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Minnesota
 
2005-10-24, 17:33

I agree that in total, the updates are worthwhile. Even the gimmicky ones, like the scrolling trackpad. Each one, though, elicits a response of "it's nice, but..." from me. They're nice, but not major. Or nice to have around, but they wouldn't be used often enough to be worth it.

What I mean isn't that the current PowerBooks are a bad deal... they're not really a bad deal at all. I wish Apple had given them a more substantial update, but at least they added a few features and simplified the line (dropping prices as a result). But if you own an older aluminum PowerBook, I don't see many compelling reasons to upgrade to a new one. And if you have a titanium PowerBook (as my dad had before he got a 1.5 GHz one just yesterday), the improvements you get from simply moving to any of the aluminum PowerBooks is going to make the distinctions between the individual revisions seem pretty small in comparison.

He ended up buying the 1.5 GHz model because it was about $200 less expensive ($1599 edu vs. $1799 edu for a new one). Yes, if he had bought a brand new one he would have gotten a lot of extra features for those $200, but none of them stood out as being worth it for him. We didn't have a lot of money to drop on this purchase so even a small decrease in price was very welcome.

So, if you are a PC user who's looking to jump into the Mac world headfirst and get a PowerBook, the new ones are awesome. If you're a Mac user for whom money is not a very major concern, the new ones are great. If you already have a pretty recent Mac but are starting to feel like you could use a new one, I think you should wait. And if you're a bit tight on money, the older ones are a great way to go because they give you almost the same machine for significantly less expense.
  quote
chucker
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: near Bremen, Germany
Send a message via ICQ to chucker Send a message via AIM to chucker Send a message via MSN to chucker Send a message via Yahoo to chucker Send a message via Skype™ to chucker 
2005-10-24, 17:44

Quote:
Originally Posted by Luca
I agree that in total, the updates are worthwhile. Even the gimmicky ones, like the scrolling trackpad. Each one, though, elicits a response of "it's nice, but..." from me. They're nice, but not major. Or nice to have around, but they wouldn't be used often enough to be worth it. [..] But if you own an older aluminum PowerBook, I don't see many compelling reasons to upgrade to a new one.
I couldn't agree more.

Quote:
He ended up buying the 1.5 GHz model because it was about $200 less expensive ($1599 edu vs. $1799 edu for a new one). Yes, if he had bought a brand new one he would have gotten a lot of extra features for those $200, but none of them stood out as being worth it for him. We didn't have a lot of money to drop on this purchase so even a small decrease in price was very welcome.
Hmm, I personally would have spent the $200. You get a slightly faster CPU, twice the VRAM, a DL DVD burner rather than a combo drive, better battery, better brightness, Safe Sleep, DDR2, and some other things I'm not thinking of.

I can see though why, on a tight budget, you might want to pick the previous model. It's a damn fine laptop just as much.

Quote:
So, if you are a PC user who's looking to jump into the Mac world headfirst and get a PowerBook, the new ones are awesome. If you're a Mac user for whom money is not a very major concern, the new ones are great. If you already have a pretty recent Mac but are starting to feel like you could use a new one, I think you should wait. And if you're a bit tight on money, the older ones are a great way to go because they give you almost the same machine for significantly less expense.
Absolutely.
  quote
Luca
ಠ_ರೃ
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Minnesota
 
2005-10-24, 17:57

$1599 was already more than we could comfortably afford. But we decided that getting an iBook would just lead to him wanting to replace it right away, since he's gotten used to the 15" wide-aspect screen over the past three years. Of the features you listed, he only would have even noticed the battery. We already have two other DVD burners in the house (one is DL), the CPU and VRAM isn't important, safe sleep isn't a very important feature IMHO, and the brightness will be better than his old Ti550 regardless of the revision.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the DDR2 actually a slight disadvantage? It has greater latency than DDR, but the G4 can't even handle the bandwidth of regular DDR, nevermind DDR2, so that advantage of DDR2 is wasted. But maybe I'm mistaken here.
  quote
chucker
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: near Bremen, Germany
Send a message via ICQ to chucker Send a message via AIM to chucker Send a message via MSN to chucker Send a message via Yahoo to chucker Send a message via Skype™ to chucker 
2005-10-24, 18:07

Quote:
Originally Posted by Luca
Of the features you listed, he only would have even noticed the battery. We already have two other DVD burners in the house (one is DL), the CPU and VRAM isn't important, safe sleep isn't a very important feature IMHO, and the brightness will be better than his old Ti550 regardless of the revision.
I see.

Quote:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the DDR2 actually a slight disadvantage? It has greater latency than DDR, but the G4 can't even handle the bandwidth of regular DDR, nevermind DDR2, so that advantage of DDR2 is wasted. But maybe I'm mistaken here.
I'm not a RAM expert, so don't ask You have a point though; the FSB of the G4 is limiting. If the DDR2 is a disadvantage, though, why would Apple bother? I was under the impression that DDR2 RAM tends to be cheaper (for whatever reason).

As for latency, bandwidth, etc., I frankly don't know.
  quote
Luca
ಠ_ರೃ
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Minnesota
 
2005-10-24, 18:25

I think it's because DDR2 uses less power. The speed difference is probably tiny and unnoticeable, though. I mean, it's CL=3 vs. CL=4... not huge. Almost certainly less than the 1.5 -> 1.67 GHz bump, which is itself pretty insignificant.

Of course, the Apple salesman said it was the fastest memory available in a laptop. That's technically correct - the DDR2 RAM modules that come with 15" and 17" PowerBooks are the same PC2 4200, DDR2 533 modules that plug into the highest end PC notebooks. Such notebooks a 533 MHz frontside bus so the RAM can communicate with the processor with no bottleneck.

The PowerBook's G4 has the same old 167 MHz frontside bus, so the fastest the RAM can communicate is as 333 MHz (because it's double data rate). The PowerBooks have DDR2 533 memory bottlenecked to DDR2 333, so it doesn't have any advantage over plain DDR333 other than the lower power consumption.

I guess we were in a special situation. For most people, the $200 would have been very well spent. Even for us, I did say it would be a good deal to get the new one, but it wasn't a good enough deal really.
  quote
OnStage
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
 
2005-10-24, 23:45

Well, i just jumped at a last gen. 15 inch at 1600$ US plus tax (refurb). I'd love the new screen, but the old one isn't half bad, and 1600 feels alot nicer than 1800 somehow!! Beyond that it looks like the same machine.... (yeah yeah RAM, but as pointed out before the FSB is the bigger problem)
my .02
john
  quote
switchr92
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Send a message via AIM to switchr92  
2005-10-25, 22:04

Guys, a quick unrelated question, what does the intel switch mean for mac gaming? The problem with current mac gaming is a mix of bad port jobs/processors with arcitecture optimised for graphics work (or so i've heard). Do you think the intel switch will make a difference?
  quote
badtzmaru
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
 
2005-10-26, 13:17

Quote:
Originally Posted by Luca
I'd say that anyone who already owns an aluminum PowerBook should NOT buy a new one. There's no reason to. Apple hasn't really improved the PowerBooks since they unified the lineup in late 2003. They haven't added any important new features, only gimmicks. The increase in clock speed is both disappointingly small and almost entirely insignificant. (additional text truncated with a ditto)
I totally agree.

I have an Apple store near me and on Oct. 23 I checked out the new 15" PowerBook 5,8 with DDR2 memory. It was possible for me to download and run Xbench on it, so I did on it and a couple of other Macs. The 15" PowerBook 5,8 with a 1.67 GHz G4 CPU got a 43.18, my current PowerBook5,2 with a 1.25 GHz CPU averages around 42 in multiple tests. A new 17" iMac G5 with a 1.9 GHz CPU scored 74, for the sake of comparison.

As someone who can do their own upgrades, I'll upgrade my current PB's hard drive and DVD drive when I get around to it, versus up-buying a new PowerBook, and go G5 iMac at home since its price and performance seem pretty decent. Even if someone can't do their own upgrades, an external DVD burner and a hard drive connected via FW800 should be cheap value extenders.

So I'd agree and say further, if you currently have an aluminum PowerBook, there's no point in moving to a new PowerBook, and I even say wait until the Intel-PowerBook is robust, tried and tested.
  quote
MacMan05
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
 
2005-11-01, 14:23

Well I decided to take the plunge and have bought myself a new 15" PB. It arrives tomorrow. I figured why wait?
  quote
DMBand0026
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Chicago
 
2005-11-01, 14:54

Quote:
Originally Posted by MacMan05
Well I decided to take the plunge and have bought myself a new 15" PB. It arrives tomorrow. I figured why wait?
Good call, congrats man.
  quote
Koodari
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
 
2005-11-01, 16:03

You can never go wrong buying right after a decent update. Personally I think upping the resolution, 128MB VRAM standard, Superdrive standard and digital sound out with same price counts as decent. (Was the keyboard already illuminated as standard or was that new too?)

They really don't have anything worthwhile left to put in anymore after this. Next stop Intel.

Luca is right though, there is nothing to make this very enticing to previous Al Powerbook owners. I guess the only good reason would be if you don't want to buy Applecare and instead plan to refresh your warranty by selling the old PB and getting a new one.
  quote
SushiE
New Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Far Rockaway, Queens, NY
 
2005-11-01, 16:03

Ok well I might as well hop on this one with my own dilemma. I have a 12" PB 1.33Ghz which I love and adore. I use it all the time from work to home and back again. Recently, a fellow co-worker has been eyeing it up and thinking of buying an iBook (i've been selling him pretty hard on it too). Concurently I've been getting sick of having my face jammed up against the screen while I work in photoshop. Seeing my dismay, he offered me a very friendly $1100 for it, given that he was thinking of getting an iBook anyways, and for him this would be a better computer at the same price. Ok so here I am, with a potential 1100 bucks, christmas around the corner, I can most likely finagle a new 15" PB for about $500-$600 of my own cash. It's either that, or buy a 21" cinema display (about 350 of my own cash after christmas $$) or do nothing. With all these compelling arguments for not upgrading, what's my next move???
  quote
Koodari
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
 
2005-11-01, 16:50

What's your warranty situation SushiE, and how is your Powerbook equipped?
  quote
MacMan05
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
 
2005-11-01, 17:03

Keyboard illumination is standard. Yes.
  quote
Franz Josef
Passing by
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: London, Europe
 
2005-11-01, 17:22

Quote:
Originally Posted by SushiE
what's my next move???
In your place, I would simply buy an external Apple display. As you point out, the 12" PB is a wonderful laptop - the external disply should ease your concerns re Photoshop. The 15" PB is a very good laptop but I find it not nearly as portable and versatile as the 12" - you may find you miss this if you upgrade.

FJ
  quote
SushiE
New Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Far Rockaway, Queens, NY
 
2005-11-02, 09:37

Well the warranty goes out on December 10th. If I try to sell it I think I would try to convince the buyer to split the cost to cover the remaining two years. This way he gets one year free (as if he bought new) and pays for one. Fair deal?

I've put in an additional 512mb ram, bringing it to 768mb. I also have the 4x superdrive. It is the model right before the scrolling pad and sudden motion sensors came out.

Franz- you have a point, now i'm really in the middle on this...
  quote
WBG4
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: San Luis Obispo, CA CPSU
Send a message via ICQ to WBG4 Send a message via AIM to WBG4  
2005-11-02, 10:06

Quote:
Originally Posted by RC23
it really depends...
buying a G4 chip right now is like buying a 1970 Ford Truck.
As long as it has 4 on the floor with granny count me in
  quote
Posting Rules Navigation
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Page 1 of 2 [1] 2  Next

Post Reply

Forum Jump
Thread Tools
Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Wait for PB update or buy iBook now? Noel Purchasing Advice 11 2005-08-29 13:51
Does the new 15" PowerBook boot up more slowly? Dave Marsh Genius Bar 12 2005-02-25 00:05
Does it make sense to wait to buy an iMac until Tiger? revolver Speculation and Rumors 3 2004-10-18 09:15
12 inch powerbook, to buy or not to buy? (need decision making help) stevegong General Discussion 8 2004-08-19 09:25
Buy Plasma TV now or wait for OLED? stevegong General Discussion 8 2004-08-13 03:25


« Previous Thread | Next Thread »

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 00:52.


Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2024, AppleNova